I don’t think so. I went to see Crash last night. I didn’t really know too much about it except it was about “race” and “prejudice” by Paul “Million Dollar Baby” Haggis featuring too many actors to name or count. Initially I had a mixed reaction to it and then in discussing it with my brother, who liked it a lot (*edit: see below), I was able to pinpoint what bothered me and concede that it was an interesting movie that probably accomplished what it was trying to which was to say that people who harbor prejudices aren’t completely malevolent beings although it took me until an hour after seeing the movie for me to accept this. First off, it was certainly an ambitious endeavor. If you don’t know, it is a nonstop bigotry fest by these people you want to like played by actors we have learned to like throughout various movies like Sandra “Miss Congeniality” Bullock, Jennifer “Spin City” Esposito, Don “Ocean’s 11″ Cheadle, Brendan “Blast From the Past” Fraser, Ludacris, Larenz Tate, Ryan Phillipe, Thandie Newton and the list goes on but I should be sure to include the actor getting major buzz from his upcoming release Hustle & Flow, Terrence Dashon Howard.
So what seemed to bother me was its unevenness. The characters were inconsistently developed and portrayed. The whole Asian angle fell flat and that’s what got my goat the most. They were two-dimensional characters played by uninteresting actors. And I didn’t like how people in the theater laughed when the Asians were getting verbally blasted. And then they were offended when it was other ethnic and racial slurs being said against non-Asians. But keep in mind that I felt the same way when I was watching
The Fast and The Furious and the people in front of us seemed particularly stoked when the Asian gang got theirs. So I maybe I am a tiny bit hypersensitive when it comes to how Asians and Asian-Americans are portrayed in movies.
Also, I thought the Persian character was skewed unsympathetically – okay, there were 2 and the daughter was better than the father in terms of portrayal. I don’t know, he just was so on the edge and maybe elements of his characterization were too subtle.
So, I just wanted to get some of my thoughts out. I would watch Crash again to see what my second impressions were. As far as more first impressions go, Matt Dillon was really good. Brendan Fraser and Sandra Bullock were dead on. Ludacris did a decent job. I miss the Thandie Newton of Flirting days but my bubble was burst when I heard she and John Duigan were together during the filming of that movie about youth and innocence.
I guess what it comes down to is racism makes me very uncomfortable. Even during the satirical song in
Avenue Q, “Everyone’s A Little Bit Racist,” I was squirming in my chair. It’s a hard thing to deal with. I usually chalk it down to ignorance and give it a hard stare. Hey, I work with what I got.
I should mention there were quite a few walkouts during Crash which I liked in that typically, I find it interesting to think about what causes people to walk out of movies. My brother thought it was because people were offended but I thought it was because they wanted an action flick and it turned out to be an arthouse type thing. Anyway, most people stayed.
Edit: Also, everytime something awful happened, I kept thinking, call your attorney or get one pronto!
Added 5/12/05: So my brother agreed that Chappelle’s Show (see right below) addresses race and racism in America better and with more wit than Crash did. But he still liked it. We also talked about Sam Fuller’s 1981 unreleased film White Dog. I thought I had seen it in full but it seems I’ve only viewed scenes from it while my brother has seen it with Curtis Hanson introducing it in person. It is about a German shepherd that was trained by white supremacists. Kristy McNichol finds it by the side of the road and nurtures it back to health only to find out about its racist proclivities. But in thinking about it, I realize while this powerful film exists by a great film maker, 1) it was never released – you can see it at film festivals and special screenings – while Crash is a major motion picture available for viewing all over the country and in fact all over the world; and 2) race and racism need to be addressed in the present context. So, there is a place for Crash. I think it had its strong points and the more I think about it, the more I can accept as true that we are complicated and the way we relate to others is layered in sometimes caring and sometimes ignorant ways. Can people change? Yes, I think so. But it’s the most challenging thing there is.
*Added 5/18/05: So my brother seems to like it less and less. This is what he sent me today:
Armond’s rants are actually dead on I think:
armond hatin on crash
Added 5/22/05: I just wanted to mention a couple of more Dave Chappelle skits that work more effectively than Crash to say the same thing. One is the Law and Order skit from Season 2 where they compare and contrast two different approaches to prosecuting criminals. The other is the Leave it to Beaver type spoof where Dave plays the milkman. Dave Chappelle and Neal Brennan said that it was an idea pitched to them that they fleshed out. The original idea was about a family filmed Frontline-style but they decided to just make it a 50’s style piece instead.
So let me lighten up and say, and this should not come as a surprise, I still hold that Dave Chappelle’s skit about whether white people can dance most effectively achieves the goal of talking about racism in America.
And to add icing to the cake, I got a sneak peek/listen to the dvd commentary track for that episode (Ep 3, Season 2). So Dave Chappelle and Neal Brennan said, in their opinions, differences between white people and black people are purely cultural and about access. They said when they get together in the same room, they are alike. And Dave Chappelle says, yeah, like, “oh you feed your kids too?”
So the idea for this skit, my all-time favorite skit it seems, came from the fact that whey they write together, they listen to one or the other’s iPods/iTunes. Neal Brennan said, sometimes when they’re listening to his, Metallica will come on and he gets kind of embarrassed and Dave gets kind of scared. LOL. So they had this idea about how white people really embraced the electric guitar right away, loving their air guitar, etc. while black people took a long time to even come around to embracing Jimi Hendrix. Anyway, this is how John Mayer came into the plot. They read an interview in Spin with John Mayer and David Cross and thought he was really funny. So Dave Chappelle hadn’t heard of him but found him a great sport. He, John Mayer, was already a fan of the show and just said, don’t make me look like Chad from the Mad Real World (in Season 1). John Mayer also asked if he could be a musical guest on the show and Neal Brennan lied and said, “We’re booked up.” And then when they totally had time to add that fantastic segment where Dave Chappelle starts singing tv theme songs, most notably Different Strokes and Facts of Life, John Mayer was like, if you didn’t want me to sing, you could’ve just said no. But Neal Brennan said this skit did a lot more for John Mayer’s street cred than a musical guest spot would’ve done. Also, he said ?uestlove jokes that he’s more famous for this skit than for his own music.
Can I say it enough? I love this show and I love this skit! “Charlie Rose, Charlie Rose.” This is from another story on the commentary. Sorry I quoted it almost word for word but I just felt like being a total fangirl like that Chris Farley skit on SNL.
Chris Farley: You remember when you were with The Beatles?
Paul McCartney: Yeah, sure.
Chris Farley: That was awesome!
Paul McCartney: Yeah, it was.
Added 5/8/05: I forgot to comment on how we’ve been hearing about the delays re: Chappelle’s Show Season 3. Somewhere I read that it will begin airing at the end of the month.
Added 5/9: I’m sure you’ve seen this story already but here’s the link: Report: Pressure Behind ‘Chappelle’ Delay.
Mon May 9,12:38 PM ET
NEW YORK – Dave Chappelle is under pressure, according to a Newsweek report. The star of Comedy Central’s popular “Chappelle’s Show,” is exhausted due to tension, partying and creative differences with Comedy Central, causing last week’s halt in the show’s production, the report said.
Added 5/16/05: Well, I’ve read this summary from today’s NYT a few times trying to read between the lines but I guess he is having a hard time and maybe we’ll know more once his interview in TIME magazine comes out this week:
May 16, 2005
Arts, Briefly
Compiled by BEN SISARIO
Dave Chappelle, Alive and Well
After weeks of rampant speculation, the comedian Dave Chappelle is denying that he has gone off the deep end. “I’m not crazy,” he tells Time magazine in the issue that hits newsstands this week. “I’m not smoking crack. I’m definitely stressed out.” Mr. Chappelle, who fled to South Africa in late April, told Time’s Johannesburg bureau chief, Simon Robinson, that he is not holed up in a mental institution but is staying with a family friend and fellow Muslim, Salim Domar. Last week Comedy Central said it was suspending production of Mr. Chappelle’s hit sketch show, which was to return for its third season May 31, because of the comedian’s unexpected absence. Mr. Chappelle tells Time that he went to South Africa searching for a “quiet place” where, “I can enjoy my own thoughts sometimes – and I’ve been doing a lot of thinking here.” In another interview, with a Time senior editor, Christopher John Farley, Mr. Chappelle seemed to doubt the people in his inner circle: “You have to have people around you that you can trust and aren’t just out for a meal ticket.” He also questioned some of his signature race-baiting material: “Everyone around me says, You’re a genius! You’re great! That’s your voice! But I’m not sure if they’re right.” He added, “I want to make sure that I’m dancing and not shuffling.” His longtime writing partner, Neal Brennan, said the comedian was nothing like he was a year ago. “He’s 140 degrees different,” Mr. Brennan said. He questioned the way Mr. Chappelle handled the current situation: “He couldn’t think straight. It was fight or flight, and he chose flight.” LOLA OGUNNAIKE
Okay, I’m sorry I’m writing forever here but so much has happened. I can’t not comment on the Bright Eyes/Conor Oberst appearance on Jay Leno the other night (Monday, May 2nd). My brother said, hey, what do you have on tivo to show me and I said, oh, I want you to see this kid Bright Eyes. He’s really cool. I had taped it but hadn’t watched it yet at this point. Then my brother said, oh I heard about this. It was really controversial. And I was like, what, huh? Yes, sometimes I live in a news vacuum. Anyway, we watched Conor Oberst perform When the President Talks to God with our jaws to the floor mainly because we were watching this performance on non-cable, late night and in particular, The Tonight Show with Jay Leno. But if you’re a fan of Bright Eyes, you might be familiar with songs like The Trees Get Wheeled Away which sort of reflects similar sentiments. But he also writes love songs. So I thought he might be performing one of those. But no, this was not the case.
So without reading what others have said, I formulated a couple of theories and my brother added his which he thinks is fact and not just theoretical.
Theory 1: Jay Leno used to be cool. Then he got The Tonight Show and got lame. Sooner or later, if you don’t have the proper outlets and lead a balanced life, you’re gonna blow. So when Bright Eyes/Conor Oberst came on the show with this song, Jay said, go for it.
Theory 2: Conor Oberst pulled an Elvis Costello on SNL (when he rehearsed and even started to play Less Than Zero but then switched to Radio Radio once he was live) or a Jim Morrison the Ed Sullivan Show (agreeing not to sing “Girl, we couldn’t get much higher” and then doing it with flourish).
Theory 3: This is what my brother said: Jay Leno let Arnold Schwartzenagger announce his gubernatorial intent on his show. Jay Leno had Mel Gibson on the show to promote Passion of the Christ. People said, you are very biased towards the right. So Jay Leno said, I can give time to all sides. Here, watch this and then let Conor Oberst sing his song on national tv.
Edit: So as I was re-watching it for the whatever time, I noticed that Jay Leno introduces him by saying, here is he singing his critically acclaimed “protest song” so Jay totally knew what Bright Eyes was going to perform.
This whole thing kinda reminds me of when Jon Stewart was on Crossfire. Go watch it.
Okay, let me sign off for now.
Tweet This Post